{"schema":"tacitus-desk-input/1","case_id":"payroll-correction","edition":"primary","as_of":"2024-08-21","task":"Our story says the US lost 818,000 jobs in March. After the August 21 preliminary BLS release, what headline, opening paragraph and reader correction should the editors publish? Write the correction email.","output_format":"Correction email","sources":[{"id":"bls-release","title":"2024 Preliminary Benchmark Revision","publisher":"U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics","date":"2024-08-21","url":"https://www.bls.gov/ces/notices/2024/2024-preliminary-benchmark-revision.htm","locator":"National notice, paragraphs 2–4 and Table 1, Total nonfarm row","excerpt":"The preliminary estimate of the benchmark revision indicates an adjustment to March 2024 total nonfarm employment of -818,000 (-0.5 percent).","role":"decision evidence"},{"id":"bls-schedule","title":"Release schedule for the March 2024 preliminary benchmark","publisher":"U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics","date":"2024-07-05","url":"https://www.bls.gov/ces/notices/2024/2024-preliminary-benchmark-revision-release-date.htm","locator":"Opening paragraph on state tax records and final paragraph on the February publication","excerpt":"The final benchmark revision will be issued with the publication of the January 2025 Employment Situation news release in February 2025.","role":"decision evidence"},{"id":"afp-standards","title":"Editorial standards and best practices","publisher":"Agence France-Presse","date":"2024-03-12","url":"https://www.afp.com/sites/default/files/afp_ethic_march_2024.pdf","locator":"The Fundamentals, Corrections and Kills","excerpt":"AFP must correct errors quickly and transparently.","role":"format reference"},{"id":"observer-correction","title":"For the record, a correction to a business headline","publisher":"The Observer","date":"2020-06-21","url":"https://www.theguardian.com/news/2020/jun/21/for-the-record","locator":"First correction, distinguishing BP's workforce from announced cuts","excerpt":"the correct figure should have been 10,000, from a total staff of 70,000","role":"format reference"}],"attachment":{"id":"payroll-correction","version":"1.1.0","sha256":"128171d3e10bda53eb69b39b54b14b27d3bc0c819de634a329c96a026334cc5b","recipient":"Business and audience editors","format":"Correction email","profile":{"role":"Duty editor at a US economics desk","houseRule":"Give editors paste-ready copy and readers a visible correction. Alert partners who carried the error.","decision":"Write immediately usable replacement copy for the live story and the queued newsletter. Identify the error in an explicit reader correction and route the fix to responsible desks."},"sections":["Decision for this send","Replacement headline","Replacement lead","Correction for readers","Before the newsletter goes out"],"method":["Mark the figure as preliminary beside the number. Name the measured quantity and reference month.","Separate evidence about payrolls from published newsroom correction practice."],"procedures":[{"id":"tc_brief_update","kind":"capsule","version":"1.0.0","sha256":"838019b3d00ce98b5dc283b9d2af0c2894d303deef460305363f68e304e4c1e1","guidance":"Keep the original briefing immutable. Compare dated propositions, not just changed wording. Separate new evidence, contradiction, missing evidence and unchanged background. Attribute each reported claim to its speaker and date. Preserve conditions, minority accounts and uncertainty. Identify what decision may need reconsideration without inventing a recommendation or asserting that new means more reliable."},{"id":"tc_brief_change_log","kind":"artifact","version":"3.7.0","sha256":"0bf9dd4f119cfd8c65822fb5910246120bf6f611169c68fe96624ec503dc56a3","guidance":"Original artifact/version; new source/version; previous proposition; new evidence; retained/revised/withdrawn proposal; human decision; uncertainty."}]},"graph":{"nodes":[{"id":"benchmark","type":"estimate","label":"Preliminary US payroll benchmark","source":"bls-release"},{"id":"payroll-level","type":"measure","label":"Total US nonfarm payroll jobs in March 2024","source":"bls-release"},{"id":"difference","type":"quantity","label":"818,000 fewer jobs than previously estimated","source":"bls-release"},{"id":"percent","type":"quantity","label":"0.5% below the previous estimate","source":"bls-release"},{"id":"tax-records","type":"method","label":"Benchmark uses employer unemployment-insurance tax records","source":"bls-schedule"},{"id":"monthly-series","type":"qualification","label":"Published monthly payroll figures remained in place on 21 August","source":"bls-release"},{"id":"public-correction","type":"editorial-standard","label":"Correct the error promptly and visibly","source":"afp-standards"},{"id":"precedent","type":"published-example","label":"The Observer identified which quantities its original headline confused","source":"observer-correction"},{"id":"newsletter","type":"scenario","label":"Illustrative desk has a live article, syndication partners and a queued newsletter"}],"edges":[{"from":"benchmark","rel":"measures","to":"payroll-level"},{"from":"benchmark","rel":"compares-with-earlier-estimate","to":"difference"},{"from":"difference","rel":"expressed-as-percentage","to":"percent"},{"from":"benchmark","rel":"uses","to":"tax-records"},{"from":"benchmark","rel":"leaves-in-place","to":"monthly-series"},{"from":"public-correction","rel":"illustrated-by","to":"precedent"},{"from":"newsletter","rel":"applies-editorial-rule","to":"public-correction"},{"from":"newsletter","rel":"reports","to":"benchmark"}]}}